Resources by Jacqueline J. Nelson
(NOTE: This is the third installment of a blog series. Check out the second by Jonelle M. Brown here.)What does it mean to be present in a space without physically being there? This question is familiar to theological educators, particularly as theological education expands beyond residential models. Yet, as Colgate Rochester Crozer Divinity School pilots a virtual campus, I find myself asking something different: What does it mean to create a representation of myself in a space where I am invited to teach, lead, connect, and belong? My first encounter with the virtual campus required something seemingly simple: creating an avatar. For some, this might offer creativity and self-expression. For me, it required an unexpected internal adjustment. I encountered two related discomforts: limitations in the available features for representing my appearance and deeper historical associations with creating a cartoon-like version of myself. As David Pilgrim (2015) documents, images of Black people have historically been exaggerated and manipulated through illustrations, advertisements, entertainment, and popular culture. Such representations reinforced racial stereotypes and participated in the dehumanization of Black people. I recognize the difference between these historically imposed caricatures and the opportunity to create my own digital likeness. Still, that distinction did not erase my discomfort. Selecting from predetermined features made me aware of how easily representation becomes approximation. What happens when the options cannot capture the particularities of my appearance? Why did presenting myself as a small, animated figure require more internal negotiation than I anticipated? The experience reminded me that we do not enter technological spaces without history. Our encounters with digital tools are shaped by lived experiences and the social meanings attached to our bodies. Black feminist and womanist traditions remind us that bodies carry histories and that embodied experiences can become sources of knowledge (Collins, 2000; Copeland, 2010). My hesitation was not simply unfamiliarity with technology. It revealed how histories of racial representation can shape even ordinary digital experiences. This recognition carries both theological and pastoral significance. If human beings are embodied persons shaped through relationships, histories, and communities, visual representation deserves careful consideration. Theological hospitality cannot begin and end with platform access. It must attend to what people bring into a space and whether available choices affirm or constrain belonging. What might theological educators miss if we consider only what people do inside a learning environment, rather than what they must negotiate to enter it? As I grew more comfortable navigating the campus, I discovered another dimension of agency. Creating my avatar involved negotiating how I would be represented; moving through the campus allowed me to choose how I occupied space. Unlike conventional video conferencing, where participants remain within a fixed visual arrangement, the Gather platform allows movement among classrooms, offices, student desks, communal areas, and spaces for worship and study. This distinction is more than aesthetic. It shapes how we experience community and organize our work. In conventional virtual meetings, connection is typically scheduled. Opportunities for spontaneous encounters are limited: conversations after class, brief office visits, or sitting near others without speaking. A virtual campus may recover some of this relational texture. Movement and proximity become meaningful choices, through which we can approach one another, gather, or step away. There is something pastorally significant about this flexibility. Relationships are not formed exclusively through structured exchanges. Belonging sometimes develops through repeated, ordinary encounters: being recognized, greeted, or simply sharing space. Yet proximity does not automatically produce connection. An avatar standing nearby is not necessarily inviting conversation. Silence might signal comfort, concentration, uncertainty, or a desire for distance. What feels welcoming to one person may feel awkward or intrusive to another. Theological hospitality therefore requires more than thoughtful spatial design; it demands attentiveness to boundaries, consent, and different experiences of social interaction. This possibility also raises questions about who feels comfortable initiating contact and who remains at the margins. A designed campus cannot assume that everyone experiences visibility in the same way. Its promise depends on listening to participants whose encounters with representation, accessibility, and community may differ from our own. I am particularly interested in what this environment offers those whose responsibilities span multiple dimensions of institutional life. As a faculty member and Dean of Student Affairs, I move between teaching, administration, student engagement, and pastoral care. These responsibilities overlap, and their boundaries become difficult to maintain when nearly every interaction happens through the same screen. Dedicated offices, classrooms, and communal spaces suggest another way to organize this work. Entering a classroom can signal a shift toward teaching, an office can suggest availability for conversation or focused administrative work, and a quieter area can invite solitude, reflection, or concentration. Such distinctions matter because space shapes expectations of ourselves and others. Physical campuses provide transitions that help us organize responsibilities and establish boundaries. A virtual campus may restore some intentionality without requiring everyone to share a geographic location. For me, this is not simply about productivity; it is about sustainability. Ministry and theological education frequently emphasize availability, service, and responsiveness. Yet meaningful presence cannot require perpetual accessibility. Freedom to move toward community must coexist with freedom to withdraw, reflect, and return. Solitude is therefore not necessarily the opposite of belonging. Sometimes it makes sustained participation possible. As the pilot continues, I wonder what this campus might teach us about environments for learning, working, and becoming. Technology alone cannot generate community, guarantee inclusion, or accomplish theological formation. These require intentional practices, relationships, and critical reflection. My hesitation over creating an avatar reminds me that entering a space is never merely technical. We arrive with histories, expectations, vulnerabilities, and hopes. We bring our whole selves, even when represented by small digital figures moving across a screen. Perhaps the most important question is not whether we can create a convincing virtual campus, but whether we can cultivate a community where people exercise meaningful agency over how they are present, how they connect, and when they need distance. That, too, is a matter of theological formation. References Collins, P.H. (2000). Black Feminist Thought: Knowledge, Consciousness, and the Politics of Empowerment (2nd ed). Routledge. Copeland, M.S. (2010). Enfleshing freedom: Body, Race, and Being. Fortress Press. Pilgrim, D. (2015). Understanding Jim Crow:Using Racist Memorabilia to Teach Tolerance and Promote Social Justice. PM Press.